Ebenezer Spoilers Ahead! (Spoiler: Not All of Them)

Dear Reader,

Word Raccoon is a Dickens enthusiast, and A Christmas Carol in particular. She’s seen many film versions of the novella, so obviously she went to see Ebenezer, the newest.

She does not usually enjoy dark films. And by that I mean films with lots of scenes with little light. She frowns because she wants to SEE everything. She knows this is irrational, but it’s just how she feels.

The movie was atmospheric, so dark in two senses, with the actual scenes as dark as Victorian England rooms would have legitimately been. And pretty much every version of A Christmas Carol portrays Dickens’s offices and rooms as having few candles or lanterns anyway. Word Raccoon found herself counting the lanterns in hallways, hoping for more light.

But in the other sense, there were sections of the film that were more terrifying than other versions. The filmy-eyed ghost of Christmas Past floats through the air and screams in Ebenezer’s face. The cemetery scenes are intense. A plot twist leaves a character murdered in an alley. (In the novella, he dies offstage.)

While the story is recognizably taken from the novella, it gently bends away from the plot in spots to good effect. For instance, in the beginning we see Scrooge and Marley both working in their offices, instead of Marley already being dead.

Ironically, Scrooge accuses the men who come to his office soliciting a donation of spending the money on their own expensive clothes, when he doesn’t give anything to charity at all.

The prize turkey goes to Scrooge’s nephew in the film, instead of to the Cratchits, a gift Ebenezer brings as an apology in hopes of reconciling with this last connection with his deceased sister. The way the turkey flops out of the basket provides needed comedy.

And the scenes with Belle, Scrooge’s romantic interest, are very different than they are in the novella. Although she loves him dearly, she realizes he loves his career more. She offers to end their relationship, and he accepts, tossing the lock of her hair he’s been carrying into the fire.

She ultimately recovers from her heartache, marries, and becomes a successful novelist. They do encounter one another again later, and he’s humbled and regretful, sending her a letter congratulating her on her book.

There is one surprise in the movie that had Word Raccoon bouncing in her seat and clapping her hands. I’m pretty sure a happy tear came to her eye, too. She thinks it a gorgeous plot twist and wishes Dickens had thought of it, something she has never said about a movie adaptation.

She wants to tell you, but no, no, no! That’s too big a spoiler.

I’d like to think that Dickens would have snapped his fingers and said he wished he’d have thought of it.

Just as Ebenezer ultimately wants to be a better person after the visitation of the three ghosts, the film reminded me of kindnesses I have always meant to do but haven’t. Maybe it’s time.

Considering that the original story was born of Dickens’s concern for the impoverished, I’d say the fact that this movie moved me means it remained faithful to Dickens’s aspirations.

Dear Reader, maybe these thoughts are too brief, so my apologies, but it’s been a day. Word Raccoon’s little eyelids are drooping. Kinda like that poor turkey in the film.

Drema

Leave a Reply